Eye for Eye

An 80-year-old man has been held in a Bisha prison since 2007 waiting for the implementation of an “eye-for-an-eye” sentence, Al-Watan daily reported recently.

The old man had shot a youth who had married his niece against his will and the bullet had hit the man’s eye.

A court had ruled that the man’s one eye be gouged out.

Media reported last month on a similar case where a man was sentenced to be surgically paralyzed after he crippled another man by stabbing him. The sentence received wide international condemnation, but the Ministry of Justice later denied the sentence and said the judge dismissed the request for such punishment.

Yet Another Saudi Official Blames Society for Women Driving Ban

There is no constitutional or regulatory barriers to prevent women from driving in Saudi Arabia, Justice Minister Muhammad Al-Isa said. This matter is up to society, the minister said, according to al-Hayat daily. This is, of course, not the first time that a Saudi senior official blames society for the ban on women driving. Earlier this year, Foreign Minister Prince Saud al-Faisal told reporters in Riyadh that women driving is a social matter that has nothing to do with politics. As we said here before, such statements by officials do not really address the issue. If the ban is a social matter, why does the government arrest women who dare to drive?

Saudi Denies Sentencing Man to Paralysis

Saudi Arabia denied that one of its courts issued a sentence to have a man surgically paralyzed on an “eye for eye” basis after he crippled another man by stabbing him in the back during a fight nearly ten years ago.

“This is untrue,” said the Ministry of Justice via its Twitter account. “This was not the sentence handed down by the judge who dismissed the request of such punishment.”

Saudi Gazette reported last month that Ali al-Khawahir was sentenced to be fully paralyzed as a punishment for causing paralysis to his best friend unless his family pays SR 1 million ($270,000) to the victim. Al-Khawahir was reportedly 14 years old when the incident happened and has been in jail since then.

The UK has urged Saudi Arabia not to carry out what now appears to be a misreported sentence, describing it as “grotesque.” London-based human rights groups Amnesty International has condemned the sentence. “That such a punishment might be implemented is utterly shocking,” said Ann Harrison, Amnesty’s Middle East and North Africa Deputy Director in a statement, “even in a context where flogging is frequently imposed as a punishment for some offenses, as happens in Saudi Arabia.”

The Ministry of Justice criticized human rights organizations for condemning Saudi Arabia based on false reports, saying confirming the accuracy of sources is one of the basics of working in the rights field. “The ministry hopes that everyone would attempt to be accurate,” MOJ said. “Fabricated and inaccurate news are offending to those who fall for them before others.

Saudi Justice Ministry Tweets Attendance Sheets of Judges

Saudi judges have a reputation of being notoriously unpunctual. The Ministry of Justice wants to change that impression. Today, MOJ’s account on Twitter started posting pictures of attendance sheets for some of its employees to show that judges report to the job on time:

Not everyone is buying it:

The Saudi judicial system, administered by conservative judges trained in Islamic Sharia, has long been criticized for being vague and lacking some of the basic safeguards of justice. Citizens often complain that cases take years in courts to be resolved due to the small number of judges.

In October 2007 King Abdullah announced a $2 billion project to reform the judiciary, but the plan has faced resistance by the old guard in the system. A shake up of the country’s top judges, announced earlier this week, may help speed up reforms according to lawyers and analysts who spoke to Reuters.

Saudi Judiciary Reform Moves Slowly

Saudi Arabia will build 180 courthouses over the next six months as part of King Abdullah’s project to reform the country’s judicial system, al-Hayat reported today.

Majed al-Adwan, who leads the project at the Ministry of Justice, told the newspaper that the ministry is working hard to provide the proper environment to help streamline the litigation procedures and using technology to speed up such procedures.

The project to overhaul the judicial system was announced in October 2007, and it included the allocation of $ 2 billion for training judges and building new courthouses.

The Saudi judicial system is administered by conservative judges trained in Islamic Sharia has long been criticized, especially after some cases in recent years that gained international attention like the Qatif Girl case. The system has been also seen as vague and lacking some of the basic safeguards of justice. Citizens complain that cases often take years in courts to be resolved due to the small number of judges.

King Abdullah’s decision to reform the system was hailed as “one of the most significant reform moves King Abdullah has made so far.”

But the old guard at the the justice ministry has reportedly resisted calls for reform, and critics of MOJ say the ministry have flooded the media with hollow promises. Saudi lawyer Bander Alno­gaithan, a Harvard law school graduate, often uses Twitter to chronicle his dissatisfaction with the country’s judiciary.

“It seems to me that the ministry has given up on reforming the judiciary on the ground and concentrated its effort on creating an ‘image’ that is totally different from reality,” he said.

The 2011 annual report for the Court of Grievances said that the 822 judges employed by the court have dealt with a total of 99,103 cases and gave rulings in 58,184 of them. 1,023 jobs at the court remained vacant, the report said.

MOJ To Hire Women

Fatima Muhammad interviews Majid Al-Adwan, head of King Abdullah Project for the Development of the Judicial System:

According to Al-Adwan, the ministry is seeking to hire [female] law graduates as well as psychologists and sociologists who will be in charge of assisting women in legal matters. “So far the ministry has allocated a section at Jeddah General Court to start welcoming women. They will then be trained according to tasks assigned,” he said.

What about law graduates who want to work as, you know, lawyers in courts? No word on that yet.