Shoura Member Sues Popular Cleric Over Retweet

Shoura Council member Issa Al-Gheith has filed a defamation suit against well-known Dawa activist Muhammad Al-Oraifi at the Riyadh District Court on Saturday.

Al-Gheith took legal action after Al-Oraifi retweeted a poem that Al-Gheith considered defamatory and insulting. Al-Gheith gave Al-Oraifi 24 hours to apologize for the retweet but the latter did not respond at which point he went to court and filed the lawsuit on the basis of Article 5.3 of the Anti-Cyber Crime Law.

This is the first case of its kind brought before a court of law, according to court sources.

In addition to being a current member of the Shoura Council, al-Ghath is a former judge who supposedly knows how the legal system works. The fact that al-Ghaith is suing al-Arefi because the latter retweeted the allegedly defamatory poem could set a precedent. It would be also interesting to see how the presiding judge in this case will deal with the fact that al-Arefi only retweeted the poem and did not tweeted it himself.

This is not the first time that al-Ghaith has taken legal action over tweets. The Shoura member has previously said he is suing conservative writer Abdullah al-Dawood for allegedly offending him on Twitter.

Shoura Memeber to Sue Conservative Writer Over Critical Tweets

A member of the Saudi Shoura Council said today that he is going to sue a conservative writer for attacking him on Twitter. Shoura member Issa al-Ghaith said that “due to the escalation of offenses on Twitter and the necessity of legal action” he is going to sue Abdullah al-Dawood, a Saudi conservative writer based in Riyadh, for accusing him of “demanding secularism” after al-Ghaith spoke in positive terms about lifting the ban on women driving.

“Filing a lawsuit is not just for the private right but also to fight this reprehensible phenomenon on Twitter,” said al-Ghaith, a former judge who is know to support King Abdullah cautious reforms. What prompted al-Ghaith to seek legal action was a tweet posted by al-Dawood on Thursday, March 21, in which he said “Westernization has mounted al-Ghaith” in the same way that a man would mount an animal to ride it.

Al-Dawood was at the center of another controversy last month when said during a television show that baby girls should be fully covered using the face veil to protect them from sexual molestation. Al-Ghaith has told AFP that he plans to sue al-Dawood as a citizen and not a member of the Shoura Council, an advisory body whose members are appointed by the King.

“Freedom on Twitter is guaranteed by Sharia and law,” al-Ghaith said. “I demand my private right. As for the public right, the state is responsible for it.”

Reformist Saudi Judge Says His House Attacked

An armed gang has repeatedly attacked the house of an influential Saudi judge in Riyadh, local media reported today. Issa al-Ghaith, a criminal court judge, told Al Arabiya that the police were slow to respond.

“My house in the Saudi capital Riyadh has been fired at by gang members who have repeatedly tried to break into my house and kidnap my family members,” he said.

Al-Ghaith is well known for supporting King Abdullah’s reform policies, including the decision to allow men and women to study together at KAUST. His views brought him him the wrath of conservatives who accused him of encouraging the Westernization of Saudi society.

The judge said he is unaware of the reasons behind the recent attack on his house and if it is related to his work in the judiciary.